Since Stengel managed the Yankees over a half century ago, it would be helpful to younger fans to compare his achievements as New York’s skipper to the much more recent tenure of Joe Torre. Casey and Torre each managed the Yankees for a dozen seasons. Both men had losing records managing other teams. Stengel’s Yankee teams won 1,149 ball games and Torre’s squads won 1,173. Stengel, managing during the era of 154-game seasons, achieved a winning percentage with New York of .623 compared to Torre’s .605. Stengel’s teams won 10 AL Pennants and 7 World Series titles while Torre’s Yankees won 6 and 4 respectively. Torre’s teams made the postseason in each of his dozen seasons as skipper under baseball’s current divisional structure that didn’t exist in Stengel’s era.
Both Managers left the Yankees reluctantly, with bitter tastes in their mouths. Stengel was let go after the Yankees lost the 1960 World Series to the Pirates during which some of his managerial decisions were questioned. Stengel insisted he was fired for “being too old.” Torre, on the other hand, turned down a one-year incentive laden contract to continue managing New York, after the team again failed to make it to the World Series in 2007. I don’t think Stengel, who was definitely the highest paid manager in the game in his day, probably averaging $75 to $100 thousand in salary per season, would have turned down the $5 million offer Torre refused.
Charles Dillon Stengel was born in Kansas City, MO on this date in 1890. His nickname is derived from the name of his hometown.
|10||1949||58||New York Yankees||AL||155||97||57||.630||1||WS Champs|
|11||1950||59||New York Yankees||AL||155||98||56||.636||1||WS Champs|
|12||1951||60||New York Yankees||AL||154||98||56||.636||1||WS Champs|
|13||1952||61||New York Yankees||AL||154||95||59||.617||1||WS Champs|
|14||1953||62||New York Yankees||AL||151||99||52||.656||1||WS Champs|
|15||1954||63||New York Yankees||AL||155||103||51||.669||2|
|16||1955||64||New York Yankees||AL||154||96||58||.623||1||AL Pennant|
|17||1956||65||New York Yankees||AL||154||97||57||.630||1||WS Champs|
|18||1957||66||New York Yankees||AL||154||98||56||.636||1||AL Pennant|
|19||1958||67||New York Yankees||AL||155||92||62||.597||1||WS Champs|
|20||1959||68||New York Yankees||AL||155||79||75||.513||3|
|21||1960||69||New York Yankees||AL||155||97||57||.630||1||AL Pennant|
|Brooklyn Dodgers||3 years||463||208||251||.453||6.0|
|Boston Braves||6 years||870||373||491||.432||6.5|
|New York Yankees||12 years||1851||1149||696||.623||1.3||10 Pennants and 7 World Series Titles|
|New York Mets||4 years||582||175||404||.302||10.0|
|25 years||3766||1905||1842||.508||4.5||10 Pennants and 7 World Series Titles|